NEW DELHI, Nov 13 (Aalimi Nation) – Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, has renewed his call for a one-on-one public debate with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, while the BJP and Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said Parliament is the proper place for such a discussion.
What Gandhi said
Gandhi made the remarks on Friday during an "Ask Me" session on Instagram. He was asked why he insisted on a public debate when the BJP had suggested Parliament as the venue. He replied that he was not allowed to speak freely in the Lok Sabha and said his microphone had been switched off in the House. The Lok Sabha Secretariat has not been reported to have responded to that claim.
The Congress leader listed several subjects that he said he was prevented from raising in Parliament: the farm laws, alleged vote irregularities, the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, China, a book by General M.M. Naravane, and Jeffrey Epstein. These are his characterisations, and the reports did not detail the sessions in which he said this happened.
Gandhi said he wanted "a one-on-one debate" and not "a debate entailing long speeches". According to one report, he said: "I guarantee that the prime minister will not remain the PM after a one-on-one debate with me."
The format he proposed
He described a format in which he and Modi would sit across a table, state their allegations against each other and question each other directly. One report said he had no objection to industrialist Gautam Adani or Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh chief Mohan Bhagwat acting as judge. No date, venue or broadcast arrangement was specified in the reports.
The response
BJP leaders dismissed the challenge. They accused Gandhi of avoiding debates in Parliament while demanding a separate public platform.
Sitharaman said Parliament already offers a forum for debate between the government and the Opposition. She urged Gandhi to show "some seriousness and responsibility" as Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha. No response from the Prime Minister or his office had been reported by the time of writing.
Background
This is not the first time Gandhi has called for a direct public exchange with the Prime Minister. The latest remarks come amid continuing political argument over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, which opposition parties have criticised and which the Election Commission is carrying out in several states and Union Territories. The Commission has said the process is meant to update and clean the rolls.
Parliamentary debates are conducted under the rules of each House, and the Speaker presides over the Lok Sabha. Questions about whether a member has been allowed to speak are generally decided by the presiding officer under those rules.
It is unclear whether the Prime Minister will respond to the challenge. The BJP's position, as stated by Sitharaman, is that the discussion should take place in Parliament, setting up a continuing disagreement over where and in what form any such exchange could happen.







